Chapter 6 · Foundations · 8 min
Subsidiary Stock Transactions: never a gain
Chapters
Captions are burned into the video. The CC button adds the player's own captions, and the site remembers that choice.
What happens when a subsidiary issues or buys back its own shares: why it is never a gain or loss for the group, and how the parent adjusts its investment and additional paid-in capital.
Transcript
The narration, word for word, in case you'd rather read it.
The puzzle
Subsidiary sells 20,000 brand-new shares to outside investors. Parent isn't part of the deal. It doesn't buy. It doesn't sell. It doesn't pay a dime. And Parent's balance sheet just grew by $128,000. It's not income, and it's not a gain. It's additional paid-in capital. This video is about where that number comes from, and why it can never touch the income statement.
Own stock
Start with one company and its own stock. When it issues shares, it debits cash, credits common stock at par, and credits additional paid-in capital for the rest. When it buys shares back, it debits treasury stock. That's a contra-equity account, not an asset. And if it resells those shares for more than it paid? It's 3,000 better off. But look at the credit. Additional paid-in capital. Not a gain. Three entries, and not one income statement account. That's the principle. A company cannot earn income by dealing with its own owners. Income comes from outsiders. Deals with owners just move equity around.
One entity
Now make it a group, and treat Parent and Subsidiary as one entity. Who owns that entity? Parent's shareholders, obviously. But also the noncontrolling interest. NCI sits inside consolidated equity. It's an ownership interest in the group, not a liability. So when Subsidiary sells new shares to outside investors, or buys shares back from them, the group is dealing with its own owners. As long as Parent keeps control, that's an equity transaction. No gain, no loss. Whatever changes for Parent goes to additional paid-in capital.
Here's the starting point for every case. Subsidiary has 80,000 shares. Parent holds 64,000 of them. 80%. Subsidiary's net assets are 1,600,000. That's $20 a share. So Parent's stake is 80% of 1,600,000: 1,280,000. The noncontrolling interest has the other 320,000. One caution about that 1,600,000. It's Subsidiary's net assets the way the consolidated statements carry them: book value, plus whatever is left of the acquisition-date fair-value adjustments. Under the equity method, Parent's investment account tracks its share of exactly that.
Shares to outsiders
Case one. Subsidiary sells 20,000 new shares to outside investors, at $30 a share. 600,000 of cash comes in, so Subsidiary's net assets grow to 2,200,000. There are now 100,000 shares, and Parent still holds its 64,000. That's 64%. Parent's percentage fell from 80 to 64. Sounds like bad news. Your turn. Before, Parent had 80% of 1,600,000. After, it has 64% of 2,200,000. Up or down, and by how much? 64% of 2,200,000 is 1,408,000. Before, it was 1,280,000. Parent's stake went up 128,000. And Parent didn't do anything. Here's why. The new investors paid $30 for shares that were backed by $20 of net assets. They overpaid by $10 a share. 200,000 in total. That premium is now shared by every owner, and Parent owns 64%. 128,000. On Parent's books: debit Investment in Subsidiary, 128,000. Credit additional paid-in capital, 128,000. Not a gain. The group dealt with its own owners.
Price vs. book
Change the price, and the answer flips. At $30, above book value, Parent's stake rises 128,000. At exactly $20, book value, the pie grows by exactly what the new owners are entitled to. 64% of 2,000,000 is still 1,280,000. Nothing shifts. No entry. At $15, below book value, the new owners got a bargain, and the existing owners paid for it. 64% of 1,900,000 is 1,216,000. Parent's stake drops 64,000. Debit additional paid-in capital. Credit the investment. There's a shortcut hiding in there. Issue price minus book value per share. Times the new shares. Times Parent's percentage after the deal. $10 times 20,000 times 64% is 128,000. Minus $5 times 20,000 times 64% is minus 64,000.
Shares to Parent
Case two. Same 20,000 new shares at $30, but this time Parent buys all of them. Parent pays 600,000, and now holds 84,000 of the 100,000 shares. 84%. Parent's investment account: 1,280,000, plus the 600,000 it just paid. 1,880,000. But 84% of Subsidiary's 2,200,000 is only 1,848,000. The investment is 32,000 too high. Same logic, pointing the other way. Parent paid a $10 premium on 20,000 shares. 200,000. The noncontrolling interest still owns 16% of Subsidiary, so 16% of that premium is theirs now. 32,000. Debit additional paid-in capital. Credit Investment in Subsidiary.
Buybacks
Case three. Subsidiary buys back 8,000 of its own shares from outside owners, at $29 each. Treasury stock. 232,000 of cash leaves. Net assets fall to 1,368,000. Only 72,000 shares are still outstanding, and Parent holds 64,000 of them. Parent's ownership jumps from 80% to almost 89%, and Parent didn't buy a single share. More ownership. Good news? Compute it. Eight-ninths of 1,368,000 is 1,216,000. Before, 1,280,000. Parent's stake fell by 64,000. Subsidiary paid the departing owners $29 for shares backed by $20. A $9 premium on 8,000 shares. 72,000. The owners who stayed absorb it, and Parent is eight-ninths of them. 64,000. Debit additional paid-in capital. Credit the investment. Percentage up, value down. That's why you never eyeball these. Compute Parent's stake before, and after.
The method
So here's the whole method, in three steps. One: Parent's stake before. The old percentage, times Subsidiary's net assets. Two: Parent's stake after. The new percentage, times the new net assets, after the cash has moved. Three: the difference. Set aside anything Parent itself paid in, and the rest goes to Parent's additional paid-in capital. Stake up: debit the investment, credit paid-in capital. Stake down: the reverse. Two footnotes. On the worksheet, Entry S simply uses the new percentages from then on. And if Subsidiary declares a stock split or a stock dividend, every owner's percentage stays the same. No entry at all.
Watch list
Your watch list. One: a company dealing with its own owners never records a gain or a loss. Two: the noncontrolling interest are owners of the group. So if Parent keeps control, it's an equity transaction, and the change goes to additional paid-in capital. Three: compute Parent's stake before and after. The percentage alone will fool you. Four: price against book value per share tells you the direction. Above book helps the existing owners. Below book hurts them. Five: stock splits and stock dividends need no entry. That's the full set. Intra-entity debt, preferred stock, cash flows, earnings per share, and stock transactions. Every one of them is the same idea you already own: figure out what each company's books say, figure out what's true for the group, and close the gap. Go read the chapter.