Chapter 6 · Foundations · 9 min

Consolidated EPS: the subsidiary thins the parent's slice

Chapters

Captions are burned into the video. The CC button adds the player's own captions, and the site remembers that choice.

Basic EPS, the treasury stock and if-converted methods, the antidilution test, and how a subsidiary's options and convertible securities thin the parent's slice of consolidated EPS.

Transcript

The narration, word for word, in case you'd rather read it.

The puzzle

Parent's income didn't change. Its share count didn't change. It has no stock options of its own. And its earnings per share just dropped, from $3.00 to $2.92. The cause isn't on Parent's books at all. It's Subsidiary's stock options. To see why, we need earnings per share from the ground up. Basic. Then diluted, with options and convertibles. Then the Chapter 6 question: how a subsidiary's securities thin out the parent's slice.

Basic EPS

Earnings per share answers one question. How much of this year's income belongs to one share of common stock? Income, divided by shares. But not all income belongs to common. You saw this in the preferred stock video. Preferred eats first. So the top of the fraction is net income, minus preferred dividends. If the preferred is cumulative, subtract this year's dividend whether it was declared or not. If it's noncumulative, subtract it only if it was declared. And the bottom isn't the share count on December 31. It's the weighted average: each share, weighted by how much of the year it was actually outstanding.

Here's Parent. It started the year with 180,000 common shares, and they were outstanding for all twelve months. On July 1, it issued 40,000 more. Those shares were only around for the second half of the year. So the first block counts in full. 180,000. The second block counts for six months out of twelve. Half of 40,000 is 20,000. Weighted-average shares: 200,000. Not 220,000. That's Parent's denominator.

Now Parent's numerator. Parent earned 500,000 from its own operations. It also owns 80% of Subsidiary. Subsidiary's income, after the worksheet's amortization, is 200,000. Parent's share: 160,000. So income to Parent's shareholders is 660,000. Parent has preferred stock that pays 60,000 a year. Preferred eats first. That leaves 600,000 for common. 600,000, divided by 200,000 weighted-average shares. Basic earnings per share: $3.00.

The what-if

Basic earnings per share counts the shares that exist today. Diluted earnings per share asks a what-if. What if everyone holding something that can turn into common stock, an option, a convertible bond, a convertible preferred share, turned it in on the first day of the year? Same income. More shares. Thinner slices. Companies report both numbers, so shareholders can see the worst case before it happens. There are two tools for the what-if. One for options. One for convertibles.

Options

Tool one, for options: the treasury stock method. Subsidiary has 25,000 stock options. Each one lets the holder buy a share for $30. The stock has averaged $50 this year. In the what-if, all of them are exercised. 25,000 new shares appear, and the company collects 25,000 times $30. $750,000. The treasury stock method assumes the company spends that cash buying back its own shares, at the average market price. Your turn. How many shares come back? 750,000 divided by $50. 15,000 shares come back. 25,000 issued, 15,000 bought back. Net new shares: 10,000. And notice the numerator never moved. Options only add shares. One warning. If the exercise price is above the market price, say $60 against a $50 stock, nobody would exercise. Those options are antidilutive. Ignore them.

Convertibles

Tool two, for convertibles: the if-converted method. Subsidiary has $400,000 of 8% bonds that can convert into 15,000 shares. Pretend they converted on January 1. Two things change. The bottom of the fraction: the bondholders are shareholders now. 15,000 more shares. The top of the fraction: there are no bonds, so there's no interest expense. 400,000 times 8%. 32,000 of interest disappears. But don't add back the whole 32,000. Interest was tax-deductible, so losing it raises the tax bill. At a 25% tax rate, the company keeps 75%. Income goes up by 24,000. Convertible preferred stock works the same way, and it's simpler. Add back the preferred dividend. There's no tax effect, because dividends were never deductible.

The test

Not every what-if makes earnings per share smaller. So each security has to pass a test. Take what it adds to the top, over what it adds to the bottom. If that's below EPS, it drags the number down. It's dilutive: include it. If it's above, it's antidilutive: leave it out. Subsidiary's bonds add 24,000 to the top and 15,000 to the bottom. $1.60 a share. Subsidiary's basic EPS is 200,000 over 100,000 shares: $2.00. $1.60 is below that. Dilutive. And options add nothing to the top, so in-the-money options are always dilutive. So, Subsidiary's diluted earnings: 200,000, plus the 24,000 of interest saved. 224,000. Diluted shares: 100,000 outstanding, plus 10,000 from the options, plus 15,000 from the bonds. 125,000. Subsidiary's earnings per share falls from $2.00 basic to $1.79 diluted. Hold on to those two totals: 224,000 and 125,000.

The group

Now the Chapter 6 question. Those options and bonds belong to Subsidiary. Why would Parent's earnings per share care? Because Parent's income includes its share of Subsidiary's income. In basic EPS, that share was 80% of 200,000. 160,000. But look at the what-if world. Subsidiary now has 125,000 shares, and Parent still holds only 80,000 of them. 80,000 over 125,000. Parent's ownership just dropped from 80% to 64%. In that world, Subsidiary's earnings are 224,000, and Parent gets 64% of them. 143,360. A slightly bigger pie, but a much smaller slice. Parent's numerator falls by 16,640, and nothing on Parent's own books has changed.

So rebuild Parent's numerator. Parent's own income, 500,000. Plus its diluted share of Subsidiary, 143,360, in place of the 160,000. Minus Parent's preferred dividends, 60,000. Income to common: 583,360. Divided by Parent's 200,000 shares. $2.92. There's the opening puzzle. Parent's earnings per share fell 8 cents because of securities that Subsidiary issued. That's the textbook's method in three moves. One: find Subsidiary's diluted earnings and diluted shares. Two: Parent's share is those diluted earnings, times the shares Parent owns, over the diluted shares. Three: put that in Parent's numerator, and then handle Parent's own securities.

Parent's own

Last step: Parent's own securities. Remember that preferred stock paying 60,000 a year? It's convertible, into 40,000 common shares. Run the test. 60,000 over 40,000 is $1.50 a share. That's below $2.92. Dilutive. So convert it. The 60,000 dividend is no longer subtracted, and 40,000 shares join the bottom. 643,360, over 240,000 shares. $2.68. Parent also has convertible bonds: 45,000 of after-tax interest, for 10,000 shares. $4.50 a share. That's above $2.68. Including them would push EPS up. Antidilutive. Leave them out. Parent reports two numbers. Basic, $3.00. Diluted, $2.68.

Watch list

Your watch list. One: the top is net income minus preferred dividends, and the bottom is weighted-average shares. Two: options use the treasury stock method. The proceeds buy back shares at the average price, and the numerator doesn't change. Three: convertibles use if-converted. For bonds, add back the after-tax interest. For preferred, add back the dividend. Four: test every security. Added earnings over added shares. Below EPS, include it. Above, leave it out. Five, the Chapter 6 piece: Parent's share of Subsidiary is Subsidiary's diluted earnings, times the shares Parent owns, over Subsidiary's diluted shares. Last video: subsidiary stock transactions.