Chapter 6 · Foundations · 7 min

Intra-Entity Debt: the loss nobody booked

Chapters

Captions are burned into the video. The CC button adds the player's own captions, and the site remembers that choice.

A quick bond refresher (carrying value and effective interest), then what happens when one company in a group buys the other's bonds from an outsider: the gain or loss nobody booked, Entry B, and Entry *B the year after.

Where Chapter 6 uses it: Q1 · Highlight and Kiort, Q4 · Paiton and Sandra and Q5 · Mona and Lisa in the homework walkthroughs.

Transcript

The narration, word for word, in case you'd rather read it.

The puzzle

Here's a puzzle. Parent buys Subsidiary's bonds from an outside investor. On Parent's books, that's just an investment. No gain, no loss. On Subsidiary's books, nothing happens at all. And yet the consolidated income statement shows a $100,000 loss. Nobody booked it. So where did it come from? This is intra-entity debt, the first topic after variable interest entities in Chapter 6. It takes two ideas you already have: a bond's carrying value, and the rule from Chapter 5: the worksheet entry is what the group really did, minus what the books say.

Carrying value

Quick refresher. A bond is two promises: the face amount at maturity, here $1,000,000, and cash interest every year, here 10% of face. $100,000. What an investor pays depends on the return they demand. Want more than 10%? Pay less than face. That's a discount. Willing to take less? Pay more. That's a premium. Two rules run everything from here. Carrying value is face, minus the unamortized discount, or plus the premium. And interest for the year is carrying value times the effective rate, the rate locked in on the day of the deal. Subsidiary issued this bond at a discount. Today its carrying value is 950,000, and its effective rate is 12%. So this year's interest expense is 950,000 times 12%: 114,000. Only 100,000 goes out in cash. The other 14,000 is added to the carrying value, which creeps up to 964,000, on its way to face.

The purchase

Now the event. December 31, 2025. Interest rates have dropped, so this bond is worth more than it used to be. An outside investor holds all of it. Parent buys the whole bond from that investor for $1,050,000. At that price, Parent earns an 8% yield. Pass one, the books. Parent: debit Investment in bonds, 1,050,000. Credit Cash. An ordinary purchase. Subsidiary: no entry. It owes the same bond it owed yesterday, still carried at 950,000. It just owes it to someone new.

The truth

Pass three, the truth. Erase the line between Parent and Subsidiary. One company paid $1,050,000 in cash to an outsider, and got its own bond back. You can't owe money to yourself. The debt is gone. The group has retired it. And what did it retire? A liability carried at 950,000. Paying 1,050,000 to make a 950,000 debt disappear is a $100,000 loss. Before I show it, try building the worksheet entry yourself. The books show an investment and a bond payable. The truth says neither exists. Entry B. Debit Bonds payable, 950,000, to remove the debt. Credit Investment in bonds, 1,050,000, to remove the asset. And the difference: debit Loss on retirement, 100,000. One more thing, and it's a classic exam trap. It's Subsidiary's bond, so you'd expect the noncontrolling interest to share this loss. Your textbook says no. The whole loss is assigned to Parent, because Parent controls both companies and made the call to retire the debt. NCI income doesn't change. Watch for that sentence when you read this section.

Next year

Now 2026. The worksheet entry was never posted to anyone's books, so both companies carry on as if nothing happened. Subsidiary records interest expense on its carrying value: 950,000 times 12%, 114,000. It pays 100,000 in cash, so its carrying value climbs to 964,000. Parent records interest income on what it paid: 1,050,000 times 8%, 84,000. It collects the same 100,000 in cash, so its premium shrinks, down to 1,034,000. Same bond. Same 100,000 check. Two different interest numbers. That's not an error. Each company amortizes its own carrying value at its own rate. And the truth? Zero. There is no bond, so there is no interest. But add the two sets of books together: 114,000 of expense, 84,000 of income. A net cost of 30,000 that the group never incurred this year. That 30,000 is a slice of the original $100,000 loss, arriving late. The gap between the two carrying values was 100,000. Now it's 70,000. By maturity, it's zero. It's your Chapter 5 equipment gain in a mirror. There, the books took the gain at once, and the group earned it over time. Here, the group takes the loss at once, and the books catch up.

Entry *B

So the 2026 entry, *B, removes everything about this bond that's sitting on the books at year end. Bonds payable: debit 964,000. Investment in bonds: credit 1,034,000. Interest income: debit 84,000. Interest expense: credit 114,000. Both gone, each at the amount its own company recorded. Don't try to make them match. Now count. Debits so far: 1,048,000. Credits: 1,148,000. We're short 100,000 of debits. And that is last year's loss. It goes to Parent's retained earnings at January 1. Same logic as every star entry in Chapter 5. The loss was recognized on last year's worksheet, but it never touched anyone's books, so beginning retained earnings is 100,000 too high. One switch. If Parent uses the full equity method, Parent already recorded the loss on its own books, through the Investment in Subsidiary account. So the debit goes to Investment in Subsidiary instead. Same rule you used for *G and *TA. And 2027? Same entry, updated balances. The plug drops to 70,000, because 30,000 of the loss already reached the books through that interest mismatch.

Watch list

Four things for your watch list. One: the gain or loss is the debt's carrying value against the price the affiliate paid. Pay more than carrying value, loss. Pay less, gain. Two: all of it belongs to Parent. Three: interest income and interest expense won't match, and they aren't supposed to. Eliminate each at its own amount. Four: in later years, the plug is the original gain or loss, minus whatever the books have already picked up. It goes to Parent's retained earnings, or to the Investment account under full equity. When you read this section, run the four passes on the textbook's example, and try to write Entry B before the book shows it to you. Next up: subsidiary preferred stock.